Top Seafood Restaurants to Visit Near Southampton, NY

There is something special about seafood dining in the Hamptons. The combination of ocean views, fresh catches, and a laid-back coastal atmosphere makes Southampton one of the best places to enjoy seafood on Long Island. Whether you are a local or just visiting, there are plenty of outstanding restaurants within a short drive that serve fresh fish, shellfish, and classic seaside favorites.

Before you head out for your next dining adventure, make sure your Lexus is ready for the ride. You can easily schedule a service appointment or explore our new Lexus models for a comfortable and stylish drive around town.

Jerry and The Mermaid

Located along the Peconic River in Riverhead, Jerry and The Mermaid offers classic coastal charm with a welcoming, family-friendly vibe. The menu features everything from local oysters and grilled fish to hearty seafood pasta and shrimp tacos. Diners can enjoy a meal indoors or out on the deck, which offers stunning water views.

It is a relaxed setting that captures the heart of East End dining—fresh, flavorful, and unpretentious. Whether you are meeting friends for happy hour or planning a weekend dinner, this spot delivers great food and a true Hamptons feel.

The Lobster Roll Restaurant

Few places represent Long Island’s seafood heritage like The Lobster Roll Restaurant, known to locals simply as “Lunch.” Famous for its perfectly toasted buttered rolls packed with fresh lobster meat, this roadside favorite is a must-visit for seafood lovers.

The atmosphere is casual and nostalgic, evoking summer drives along Montauk Highway. It is just a short trip from Southampton and ideal for a family lunch or a spontaneous meal after a day at the beach.

Inlet Seafood Restaurant

Inlet Seafood Restaurant is run by six local fishermen who take pride in serving the freshest catches on the East End. The restaurant overlooks the water and provides some of the most picturesque dining views near Southampton.

Guests can enjoy everything from sushi rolls to whole grilled fish, complemented by a thoughtful wine list. The casual yet refined setting makes it perfect for both date nights and celebrations. Fresh, local, and sustainable—Inlet Seafood embodies everything people love about dining on Long Island’s coast.

Cowfish in Hampton Bays

Set along the Shinnecock Canal, Cowfish is one of Hampton Bays’ most popular waterfront dining spots. The restaurant features a modern coastal menu with dishes like crab-stuffed flounder, ahi tuna bowls, and flavorful seafood tacos.

The lively bar scene and scenic deck make it ideal for sunset dining. Whether you come by car or by boat, Cowfish delivers delicious seafood and a vibrant atmosphere that captures the best of the Hamptons lifestyle.

RUMBA Island Inspired Cuisine and Rum Bar

For a taste of the tropics right here on Long Island, visit RUMBA Island Inspired Cuisine and Rum Bar in Hampton Bays. This island-style restaurant serves fresh seafood with a Caribbean twist, including mahi tacos, coconut shrimp, and jerk-seasoned fish.

Guests can relax on the waterfront deck while sipping tropical cocktails and enjoying live music. The laid-back vibe makes RUMBA a favorite for both locals and visitors seeking something fun and flavorful after a day by the water.

Harvest on Fort Pond

If you are in the mood for a slightly longer drive, Harvest on Fort Pond in Montauk offers an upscale waterfront dining experience worth the trip. The restaurant overlooks Fort Pond and combines rustic charm with a refined menu featuring fresh seafood, house-made pastas, and locally sourced produce.

It is an ideal destination for a romantic dinner or special occasion. With its warm atmosphere and focus on high-quality ingredients, Harvest on Fort Pond remains a top-rated spot for anyone who appreciates the art of coastal dining.

Plan Your Seafood Adventure

Before heading out to enjoy these local favorites, take a few minutes to make sure your Lexus is ready for the journey. Book your next appointment through our service department and keep your vehicle in top shape for all your Hamptons drives. You can also check out our pre-owned inventory or browse our special offers for exceptional value on luxury vehicles built to handle every coastal adventure.

Celebrate Coastal Dining with Lexus of Southampton

From lively waterfront decks to cozy seaside cafés, the Southampton area is full of incredible seafood restaurants waiting to be discovered. Each destination captures the unique charm of Long Island’s East End, blending fresh ingredients, scenic views, and warm hospitality.

As you plan your next outing, let Lexus of Southampton be your trusted local partner for all your automotive needs. Whether you are planning a weekend cruise to Cowfish or a sunset dinner at RUMBA, your Lexus will make every drive as memorable as the meal.

Explore more lifestyle guides, local attractions, and driving tips on our blog. Wherever you go this season, enjoy the journey and savor the taste of the Hamptons—one seafood restaurant at a time.

Image by Fellipe Ditadi under the Unsplash License